Mixing Syntaxes

screenshot beginner.gifscreenshot tip08.gif

What combinations of search syntaxes will and will not fly in your Google search?


There was a time when you couldn't "mix" Google's special syntaxes [Section 1.5] - you were limited to one per query. And while Google released ever more powerful special syntaxes, not being able to combine them for their composite power stunted many a search.

This has since changed. While there remain some syntaxes that you just can't mix, there are plenty to combine in clever and powerful ways. A thoughtful combination can do wonders to narrow a search.

The Antisocial Syntaxes

The antisocial syntaxes
are the ones that won't mix and should be used individually for maximum effect. If you try to use them with other syntaxes, you won't get any results.

The syntaxes that request special information - stocks: [Tip #18], rphonetutorial:, bphonetutorial:, and phonetutorial: [Tip #17] - are all antisocial syntaxes. You can't mix them and expect to get a reasonable result.






The other antisocial syntax is the link:
syntax. The link: syntax shows you which pages have a link to a specified URL. Wouldn't it be great if you could specify what domains you wanted the pages to be from? Sorry, you can't. The link: domain does not mix.

For example, say you want to find out what pages link to O'Reilly & Associates, but you don't want to include pages from the .edu domain. The query link:www.oracle.com -site:edu will not work, because the link: syntax doesn't mix with anything else. Well, that's not quite correct. You will get results, but they'll be for the phrase "link www.oracle.com" from domains that are not .edu.

If you want to search for links and exclude the domain .edu, you have a couple of options. First, you can scrape the list of results [Tip #44]


and sort it in a spreadsheet to remove the .edu domain results. If you want to try it through Google, however, there's no command that will absolutely work. This one's a good one to try:

inanchor:oracle -inurl:oracle -site:edu

This search looks for the word O'Reilly in anchor text, the text that's used to define links. It excludes those pages that contain O'Reilly in the search result (e.g., oracle.com). And, finally, it excludes those pages that come from the .edu domain.

But this type of search is nowhere approaching complete. It only finds those links to O'Reilly that include the string oracle - if someone creates a link like «a href="http://perl.oracle.com/"»Camel Tutorial«/a», it won't be found by the query above. Furthermore, there are other domains that contain the string oracle, and possibly domains that link to oracle that contain the string oracle but aren't oracle.com. You could alter the string slightly, to omit the oracle.com site itself, but not other sites containing the string oracle:

inanchor:oracle -site:oracle.com -site:edu

But you'd still be including many O'Reilly sites that aren't at O'Reilly.com.

So what does mix? Pretty much everything else, but there's a right way and a wrong way to do it.

How Not to Mix Syntaxes

  • Don't
    mix syntaxes that will cancel each other out, such as:
    site:ucla.edu -inurl:ucla
    
    Here
    you're saying you want all results to come from ucla.edu, but that site results should not have the string "ucla" in the results. Obviously that's not going to result in very much.
  • Don't overuse single syntaxes, as in:
    site:com site:edu
    
    While you might think you're asking for results from either .com or .edu sites, what you're actually saying is that site results should come from both simultaneously. Obviously a single result can come from only one domain. Take the example perl site:edu site:com. This search will get you exactly zero results. Why? Because a result page cannot come from a .edu domain and a .com domain at the same time. If you want results from .edu and .com domains only, rephrase your search like this:
    perl (site:edu | site:com)
    
    With the pipe character (|),

    you're specifying that you want results to come either from the .edu or the .com domain.
  • Don't
    use allinurl: or allintitle: when mixing syntaxes. It takes a careful hand not to misuse these in a mixed search. Instead,
    stick to inurl: or intitle:. If you don't put allinurl: in exactly the right place, you'll create odd search results. Let's look at this example:
    allinurl:perl intitle:programming
    
    At first glance it looks like you're searching for the string "perl" in the result URL, and the word "programming" in the title. And you're right, this will work fine. But what happens if you move allinurl: to the right of the query?
    intitle:programming allinurl:perl
    
    This won't get any results. Stick to inurl: and intitle:, which are much more forgiving of where you put them in a query.
  • Don't use so many syntaxes that you get too narrow, like:
    title:agriculture site:ucla.edu inurl:search
    
    You might find that it's too narrow to give you any useful results. If you're trying to find something that's so specific that you think you'll need a narrow query, start by building a little bit of the query at a time. Say you want to find plant databases at UCLA. Instead of starting with the query:
    title:plants site:ucla.edu inurl:database
    
    Try something simpler:
    databases plants site:ucla.edu
    
    and then try adding syntaxes to keywords you've already established in your search results:
    intitle:plants databases site:ucla.edu
    
    or:
    intitle:database plants site:ucla.edu
    

How to Mix Syntaxes

If you're trying to narrow down search results, the intitle: and site: syntaxes are your best bet.

Titles and sites

For example, say you want to get an idea of what databases are offered by the state of Texas. Run this search:

intitle:search intitle:records site:tx.us 

You'll find 32 very targeted results. And of course, you can narrow down your search even more by adding keywords:

birth intitle:search intitle:records site:tx.us

It doesn't seem to matter if you put plain keywords at the beginning or the end of the search query; I put them at the beginning, because they're easier to keep up with.

The site: syntax, unlike site syntaxes on other search engines, allows you to get as general as a domain suffix (site:com) or as specific as a domain or subdomain (site:thomas.loc.gov). So if you're looking for records in El Paso, you can use this query:

intitle:records site:el-paso.tx.us

and you'll get seven results.

Title and URL

Sometimes you'll want to find a certain type of information, but you don't want to narrow by type. Instead, you want to narrow by theme of information - say you want help or a search engine. That's when you need to search in the URL.

The inurl: syntax will search for a string in the URL but won't count finding it within a larger URL. So, for example, if you search for inurl:research, Google will not find pages from researchbuzz.com, but it would find pages from www.research-councils.ac.uk.

Say you want to find information on biology, with an emphasis on learning or assistance. Try:

intitle:biology inurl:help

This takes you to a manageable 162 results. The whole point is to get a number of results that finds you what you need but isn't so large as to be overwhelming. If you find 162 results overwhelming, you can easily add the site: syntax to the search and limit your results to university sites:

intitle:biology inurl:help site:edu

But beware of using so many special syntaxes, as I mentioned above, that you detail yourself into no results at all.

All the possibilities

It's possible that I could write down every possible syntax-mixing combination and briefly explain how they might be useful, but if I did that, I'd have no room for the rest of the tips in this tutorial.

Experiment. Experiment a lot. Keep in mind constantly that most of these syntaxes do not stand alone, and you can get more done by combining them than by using them one at a time.

Depending on what kind of research you do, different patterns will emerge over time. You may discover that focusing on only PDF documents (filetype:pdf) finds you the results you need. You may discover that you should concentrate on specific file types in specific domains (filetype:ppt site:tompeters.com). Mix up the syntaxes as many ways as is relevant to your research and see what you get.